Every element of the band’s back catalogue can be found here, polished and presented just differently enough to give long time fans a reason to get excited. Scars & Stories may be nothing more than a pleasant retread of The Fray’s established style, but it does a commendable job of delivering quality in lieu of novelty. No matter where you look though, Scars & Stories is an album teeming with gorgeous instrumentation and lush balladry that will satisfy both the upbeat optimist and the dejected hopeless romantic. Another likely to be overlooked gem is ‘48 to Go’, whose layered high piano notes, chimes, and bells all ring out together to embody a sense of unbridled delight that is rather uncharacteristic of The Fray’s true-to-form sense of melancholy. If ‘The Wind’ were to be an example of the former, then ‘I Can Barely Say’ is certainly a prime illustration of the latter, with slowly echoing piano notes joined by moving strings and regret-tinged lyrics that cause it to swell with a sense of romanticism. ‘Heartbeat’ and ‘The Fighter’ may be more direct and radio-friendly in their approach, but there is still a plethora of diamonds in the rough to be discovered, such as the cascade of sprightly piano notes at the commencement of ‘The Wind’, or the drawn-out, wistful chants of “it won’t be the same” on ‘1961.’ The pianos throughout Scars & Stories have an elastic feel to them, bouncing all over the album sometimes in a bout of joy and other times in a state of hopeless reflection. The beautifully crafted harmonies go hand-in-hand with the delicate but agile arrangements that The Fray have become so well known for. While providing a beautiful complement to an otherwise pedestrian electric guitar display, the melodies on ‘Heartbeat’ send Scars & Stories on its way in an uplifting, almost spiritual mood.
It features a melody more liberating than anything they have produced since ‘How to Save a Life’, with ooh’s in the chorus that would have felt right at home on Mylo Xyloto. ‘Heartbeat’, for instance, is quintessential Fray. There is once again an emphasis on tune sense, which can be heard from Isaac Slade’s heartfelt (albeit nasally) vocals to the pianos which serve as the music’s steadfast foundation. The crystallization of their style is more evident than ever, with crashing cymbals, elated bells, and the occasionally heavy riff to drive everything home. That is one aspect that has never troubled The Fray, and Scars & Stories continues their trend of refining and honing in on their product. If a band is to rest in its laurels yet remain vital, consistency is a must. It is no wonder then that their latest offering, Scars & Stories, chooses to defend the band’s empire instead of pushing towards newer and greener pastures.
With a flair for poignancy and an undeniable knack for expressive eloquence, The Fray have garnered significant respect within both the alternative and the mainstream communities. Their music, while noticeably fluffy and inoffensive, is equally if not more contagious. Within those confines, however, it is difficult to say that they have ever done anything conspicuously wrong. They conform to the stringencies of modern pop, carefully tucking themselves into the same corner as soft-rock titans like Coldplay, Snow Patrol, Keane, and The Script.
The Fray have never done anything unexpected. Review Summary: The Fray continue plodding down paths already traveled, succeeding in spite of their resemblance to other contemporary piano-rock outfits.